• About this site
    • About
    • Staff
    • Comment Policy
    • Our Header Images
    • Review Copies and What We Cover
    • The Suggestion Box
    • FTC Disclosure
No Flying No Tights
  • Comics 101
    • Start here!
    • Ask the Comics Librarians
  • comics
  • manga
  • anime
  • Browse
    • Our Starred Titles
    • Our School Titles
    • By Intersectionality
    • By Creator
  • Lists
    • Staff Picks
    • Classic Fantastic
    • Core Collection Lists
    • Must Have
  • Send Us Review Copies
Select Page

When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement!

by Liz | Jul 16, 2024

Fairies like nothing better than practical jokes and being entertained. One of their favorite pranks was to switch a human baby with a fairy baby, except fairy babies are less common. So, one enterprising fairy decides to switch two human babies: one a commoner and the other a noble. Anna grows up in a noble household surrounded by rumors and comments from those around her about how she doesn’t fit in with her family. Her magic is different; her eyes and hair are different. No one stands up for her except her brother, Henry, and eventually her fiancée, Ed.

While crying in the garden one day after a particularly hurtful comment, Anna hears a fairy wondering about her situation. The fairy is surprised when Anna talks back and even more so when she captures him during a wager. When the fairy confirms her fears about not being a part of this family, Anna forges a pact with him to teach her magic and about how commoners live. She knows she should tell her family, but she’s scared of what might happen to her.

This is the first volume in a manga series with a long, self-explanatory title; however, although Anna is just starting to like her fiancée and worries about her engagement being broken, the family doesn’t discover the switch until the very end of this volume. Presumably, with the family’s reaction to their real daughter, and particularly Henry’s, the engagement will be addressed in a future volume. The first volume does a good job setting up the world and giving hints into what Anna might be facing. She tries to prepare herself for life as a commoner by learning skills like cooking and sewing.

This would be a good addition to any library collection as it examines the differences between nobility (rich) and commoners (poor) from the inside and also digs into the emotions of belonging. I would make sure to purchase volumes one and two at the same time (volume 3 releases soon) so that a reader isn’t left with the awful feeling of volume one’s familial rejection at the end. Teenagers and mature tweens would be the best audience for this series; however, adults will also enjoy the story telling and delicate artwork that evokes a range of emotions and showcases the noble finery Anna lives in. My hope for the next volume is that the artwork displays the differences between the nobles and the commoners to match that exploration.

When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! 
By Kenzi Oiwa
Art by  Kaoru Takanashi, Kaya Kuramoto, Liz Hollendonner,  Liz Hollendonner
Yen Press, 2023
ISBN: 9781975362430

Publisher Age Rating: Teen

NFNT Age Recommendation: Older Teen (16-18), Teen (13-16)

  • Liz

    she/her | Assistant Professor

    Reviewer

    Elizabeth Hollendonner is an Assistant Professor for Staley Library at Millikin University. She has been reading and enjoying graphic novels and manga since grade school, took a comics class under Dr. Carol Tilley and a book review class under Dr. Deborah Stevenson while earning her Master of Science in Library and Information Science degree.

    View all posts
    Recent Posts

    This Slavery

    Forgive-Me-Not

    Everything in Color

    Star Trek Lower Decks: Second Contact

    Creative Writing with Miss Mary Mac

Liked it? Take a second to support us on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Related Posts

Meems and Feefs: The Council of Ferrets News From the Fallout Small Magics
  • Liz
Support No Flying No Tights on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Reviews in your inbox!

Our weekly email arrives every Monday with our most recent reviews, lists, and recommendations.

You're on the list! Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Check out our Must-Have lists featuring the core characters and series hand picked by our staff.

Our school picks highlight titles especially great for students doing research and looking for engaging reads.

Looking for a specific type of character? Browse through our titles through the lense of underrepresented identities.

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Past Posts

Recent Posts

  • Meems and Feefs: The Council of Ferrets
  • Comics by Mood: Comics to Read When You’re…Happy
  • News From the Fallout
  • Small Magics
  • Bedford Street

Recent Comments

  • Sean Michael Wilson on The Book of Five Rings – A Graphic Novel
  • Lisa on Anime Club Picks: Crunchyroll
  • Analicia13 on My Favorite Thing Is Monsters
  • Ron McCutchan on Barakamon, vols 1-8
  • Bill on What to Read Next: Ten Titles to Try If You Love Amulet
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • RSS
@ Copyright No Flying No Tights 2023