• About this site
    • About
    • Staff
    • Comment Policy
    • Our Header Images
    • Review Copies and What We Cover
    • The Suggestion Box
    • FTC Disclosure
No Flying No Tights
  • Comics 101
    • Start here!
    • Ask the Comics Librarians
  • comics
  • manga
  • anime
  • Browse
    • Our Starred Titles
    • Our School Titles
    • By Intersectionality
    • By Creator
  • Lists
    • Staff Picks
    • Classic Fantastic
    • Core Collection Lists
    • Must Have
  • Send Us Review Copies
Select Page

Serafina and the Black Cloak

by Kendra | May 22, 2023

Who could resist exploring beautiful woods that surround the only place you’ve ever known? Serafina stays within the walls of the Biltmore Estate, following her Pa’s wishes; as long as she can but how can she stay inside when children start mysteriously disappearing?

This graphic novel edition of the best-selling quartet fantasy novel series by the same name has been well adapted into this new format. Adapting author, Michael Moreci, stays true to the magic you find in the original book series written by author Robert Beatty. 

Serafina’s story starts off tragically. She was born malformed with a strange back and collarbone, with eyes closed and the wrong number of toes. The Biltmore Estate’s maintenance man found her in the forest near the estate and brought her back to hope the nuns would help her. They called her a demon child. He feared they would kill the baby so he secretly kept her to raise by himself. He loved on that little baby and she finally opened her eyes for the first time under his loving care. 

It was heartbreaking for Serafina to learn the story of her beginnings when she was a young child, but there was a piece of her that felt such immense gratitude and love for her Pa that it strengthened their relationship even more. The story picks up quickly as the man with the black cloak is introduced and strange things start happening around the estate. Children start to go missing, the electricity stops working, and it’s clear right away to Serafina that something is wrong with this man with the black cloak as she finds his dropped glove, lost in haste, filled with large chunks of old, hairy, shedding skin.

The artwork, by Braeden Sherrell, is so beautifully done and created in a style that is absolutely perfect for this rather dark children’s tale. A lot of text keeps the story moving and keeps details consistent with the original book. Pages are colored to match the mood of the current scene in the story. Bright yellows for daytime cheerfulness or dark purples and blues splash across pages to highlight the darkness of not only the nighttime but of the situations that characters face. 

Overall, this is a wonderful adaptation of the original book. I hope they do continue on this series and create the next 3 in this children’s fantasy quartet. The story follows a typical hero’s journey pathway with tragedy and challenges to overcome that strengthen the protagonist and help her to grow, learn her strengths and conquer.

Serafina and the Black Cloak  Vol. 1
By Robert Beatty, Michael Moreci and Braeden Sherrell
Disney, 2023
ISBN: 9781368076906

Publisher Age Rating: 8-12

NFNT Age Recommendation: Middle Grade (7-11)

  • Kendra

    She/Her |

    Reviewer

    Kendra Perkins has worked at libraries in Canada, the U.A.E., China and South Korea where she has been everything from Founding Head Librarian to volunteer. She was Ambassador of China for the International Librarians Network, and she was elected to be Coordinator for the Shanghai Librarians Network (SLN), which is a community of almost 100 library professionals from more than 20 schools. She has completed her ALA accredited Masters in Library and Information Studies program at the University of Alberta. She has traveled to over 90 countries, learned to speak basic Mandarin Chinese along the way and kept up with too many graphic novel series to keep count. She has led workshops, created webinars and done library consultations in fun places like Italy and Hong Kong. She has been a guest blogger for multiple technology and education related websites and is a published book reviewer for Urban Family magazine. Find out more at her website, which she should update more frequently: http://www.theinspiredlibrarian.com

    View all posts
    Recent Posts

    Fann Club: Batman Squad:

    Courage to Dream: Tales of Hope in the Holocaust

    Algorithmic Reality

    Clementine Fox and the great island adventure

    Pup and Dragon: How to Catch an Elf

Liked it? Take a second to support us on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Related Posts

Meems and Feefs: The Council of Ferrets Small Magics Saint Seiya: Dark Wing Vol. 1
  • Kendra
Support No Flying No Tights on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Reviews in your inbox!

Our weekly email arrives every Monday with our most recent reviews, lists, and recommendations.

You're on the list! Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Check out our Must-Have lists featuring the core characters and series hand picked by our staff.

Our school picks highlight titles especially great for students doing research and looking for engaging reads.

Looking for a specific type of character? Browse through our titles through the lense of underrepresented identities.

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Past Posts

Recent Posts

  • Meems and Feefs: The Council of Ferrets
  • Comics by Mood: Comics to Read When You’re…Happy
  • News From the Fallout
  • Small Magics
  • Bedford Street

Recent Comments

  • Sean Michael Wilson on The Book of Five Rings – A Graphic Novel
  • Lisa on Anime Club Picks: Crunchyroll
  • Analicia13 on My Favorite Thing Is Monsters
  • Ron McCutchan on Barakamon, vols 1-8
  • Bill on What to Read Next: Ten Titles to Try If You Love Amulet
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • RSS
@ Copyright No Flying No Tights 2023