• About this site
    • About
    • Staff
    • Comment Policy
    • Our Header Images
    • Review Copies and What We Cover
    • The Suggestion Box
    • FTC Disclosure
No Flying No Tights
  • Comics 101
    • Start here!
    • Ask the Comics Librarians
  • comics
  • manga
  • anime
  • Browse
    • Our Starred Titles
    • Our School Titles
    • By Intersectionality
    • By Creator
  • Lists
    • Staff Picks
    • Classic Fantastic
    • Core Collection Lists
    • Must Have
  • Send Us Review Copies
Select Page

The Apothecary Diaries, vols 1-4

by Liz | Jan 12, 2024

Maomao finds herself sold into service at the Inner Court after being kidnapped while harvesting plants in the area near her home. Although she tries to keep a low profile, Maomao warns two distinguished consorts that their face powder is poisonous to their babies. Unfortunately, only one heeds the warning and the other loses her baby soon after giving birth. Once Sir Jinshi, the eunuch in charge, learns that Maomao is an aspiring apothecary, he puts her to work as a lady-in-waiting for Consort Gyokuyo. Maomao’s primary job is to act as a food taster, but Sir Jinshi has other problems where he can use her skills. Maomao is not only good at detecting poison but also at deducing motivations and linking series of events. Her medicinal skills outshine the doctor on staff as well.

Over the course of the first four volumes, Maomao helps identify a poisoner, nurses a distinguished consort on the brink of death back to health, saves a courtesan and her patron during a short visit home, explains a bullying situation within the Inner Court, and is dismissed from service before her term is officially complete. Although she misses her family, Maomao discovers she enjoys working in the Inner Court, especially when her other option is to sell her services as a courtesan in the brothel she was raised in.

Normally, I prefer some element of fantasy in my historical stories. However, there is very little reference to anything paranormal or fantastical in this series. Instead, I was captivated by the hidden depth of our main character, Maomao, and the court intrigue of the Chinese imperial palace. I have no idea how accurate any of the portrayals are, so I can’t speak to authenticity, but it makes for a very compelling story. Besides giving each character their own growth throughout, the author develops the relationships between characters with the same care. There are plenty of mystery elements and procedural tropes sprinkled in to add another layer to everything.

I started my own relationship with this world by watching the anime first, then discovering the manga when I grew impatient waiting for new episodes to release. I do prefer the colorful anime sequences, but the manga’s illustrator does a great job capturing the right amount of detail and emotion without becoming too busy or losing the important moments. Each character’s eyes are expressive and the clothing style differences for each layer of society does a great job setting the scene. There is some discussion of the emperor’s nightly visits and a consort’s job to produce heirs, as well as discussion of the dangers of ingesting too much poison. This is not the main focus and there is no on page sex depicted. This series will have wide appeal from early teens though adults and will do well in any public library collection. I highly recommend this series.

A note about the anime: The second part of The Apothecary Diaries is set to simulcast on Crunchyroll this winter. Part one featured twelve episodes that animate the events drawn in volumes one through four of the manga. The anime follows the manga closely, so if you have readers who can’t wait for the next anime episode to release, the first ten volumes of the English manga are available for purchase in physical format. If you have readers who are looking for even more of this world and these characters, there are several volumes of light novel that have been translated into English in electronic format. However, they will not start becoming available for purchase in physical format until May of this year.

The Apothecary Diaries, vols 1-4
By Natsu Hyuuga
Art by Nekokurage Hollendonner
Square Enix, 2020
Vol 1 ISBN: 9781646090709
Vol 2 ISBN: 9781646090716
Vol 3 ISBN: 9781646090723
Vol 4 ISBN: 9781646090730

Publisher Age Rating: Teen
Related media: Anime

NFNT Age Recommendation: Adult (18+), Older Teen (16-18), Teen (13-16), Tween (10-13)

  • Liz

    she/her | Assistant Professor

    Reviewer

    Elizabeth Hollendonner is an Assistant Professor for Staley Library at Millikin University. She has been reading and enjoying graphic novels and manga since grade school, took a comics class under Dr. Carol Tilley and a book review class under Dr. Deborah Stevenson while earning her Master of Science in Library and Information Science degree.

    View all posts
    Recent Posts

    This Slavery

    Forgive-Me-Not

    Everything in Color

    Star Trek Lower Decks: Second Contact

    Creative Writing with Miss Mary Mac

Liked it? Take a second to support us on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Related Posts

No Man’s Land The Juniper Lodge News From the Fallout
  • Liz
Support No Flying No Tights on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Reviews in your inbox!

Our weekly email arrives every Monday with our most recent reviews, lists, and recommendations.

You're on the list! Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Check out our Must-Have lists featuring the core characters and series hand picked by our staff.

Our school picks highlight titles especially great for students doing research and looking for engaging reads.

Looking for a specific type of character? Browse through our titles through the lense of underrepresented identities.

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Past Posts

Recent Posts

  • Instant Noodles and Beyond
  • No Man’s Land
  • The Juniper Lodge
  • Max, A Little Axolotl
  • Midsummer Sisters

Recent Comments

  • Sean Michael Wilson on The Book of Five Rings – A Graphic Novel
  • Lisa on Anime Club Picks: Crunchyroll
  • Analicia13 on My Favorite Thing Is Monsters
  • Ron McCutchan on Barakamon, vols 1-8
  • Bill on What to Read Next: Ten Titles to Try If You Love Amulet
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • RSS
@ Copyright No Flying No Tights 2023