When we are young the world can seem magical and full of untold possibilities. It’s when we get older and more perceptive, if not wiser, that the magic can fade and reality becomes more apparent. This transition from childhood to adulthood is a rite of passage for all of us and a time that can define who we become as people.
Comet Club is set in present day China, and follows the lives of Li Yu and his friend Yang Kuaikuai as they find themselves on that same precipice between childhood and adolescence. As their time in middle school nears an end they are at a crossroads. Li Yu, the troublemaker of the two, is stuck in the pair’s small mountain town while Yang Kuaikuai, the more studious one, is trying to decide if he will stay in town with his father or move to the ‘big city’ with his mother, who left him and his father when he was very young. With their time potentially running out, Li Yu wants to make the most of what time they do have and drags the more skeptical Yang Kuaikuai to the Comet Club, a group of students that discuss UFO sightings and the possibility of extraterrestrial life visiting their mountain town. The club is led by the handsome, charming, and very intelligent Qi Ming, who beat out Yang Kuaikuai for first place in their school’s math competition. For this reason and out of morbid curiosity, he agrees to hear the club members out and join. Soon strange lights in the mountains bring the club members out of their comfortable homes in the town and up in the harsh winter wilderness above. And it is in that bleak landscape that the kids shed their childlike naivete and see things for what they truly are.
Comet Club is a coming of age story very similar to such hallmarks of the genre as Stand by Me, showcasing the bonds of childhood friendship that hold a group of characters together and the cracks that form as time and circumstance begin to take their effects on who those kids are developing into. Through the characters’ parental figures the reader is given insight into what shaped the characters into who they are and insight into the choices the characters are making to distance themselves from their parents and their expectations or to seek out and meet those expectations. Li Yu’s drunken father set no expectations whatsoever leading him to take things less seriously and become a class clown. Yang Kuaikuai’s mother leaving when he was so young creates a need to prove that he is good enough to be worthy of her withheld love. Qi Ming’s father is working overseas in Japan and sends him letters and gifts such as a telescope, encouraging him to literally and figuratively reach for the stars, while at the same time hiding a dark secret of his own that also will play into his son’s future.
Creator Li Yang imbues the story with a realistic sense of angst, uncertainty, and youthful idealism. Her artwork lies somewhere between realism and fantastical which really drives home the story’s place in the transitional period between the main characters’ childhood perspectives and the burgeoning reality slowly descending upon them. Regardless of their circumstances or in what country the reader was born, the plotline is universally relatable making it a great read for teenagers going through many of the same things.
Comet Club
By Yi Yang
Fantagraphics, 2026
ISBN: 9798875002564
Company Age Rating: Teen
NFNT Age Recommendation: Middle Grade (7-11)
Creator Representation: Chinese,
Character Representation: Chinese,
